The Xanadu Dream

Hello

Hello there

Hello there

hi

Hi

Hallo

hallo

hi

hi

Hello see this

this is some great information here.

This is great information here

this is great information here.

this is great information here.

@David: You beat me to it.

@Jeff: ā€œvisionary who came up with the original idea of clickable linksā€. Not even close.

Memex was conceived when Ted Nelson was still in short pants. Hardly an original concep.

Xanadu as a product is obviously dead and had flaws from the beginning - but the ideas behind still shows the limitations of the Web and todays computer systems.

One of the most stupid limitations is Copy & Paste: You copied the ā€œ17 rules of Xanaduā€ from the Xanadu FAQ but the reader has to reconstruct the connection. It is not obvious who wrote the original list (Andrew Pam at some time between 1994 and 2002) and whether you modified something or not (you modifed the numbering schema). I would prefer a Wiki-like diff with your article at one side and the source at the other and then browse the version history of the FAQ to see when which sections were added.

If Copy & Paste would be implemented as something like ā€˜cloneā€™ and ā€˜mergeā€™ from revision control systems, we almost had a kind of Xanadu.

True, but because of ā€œfreeā€ most of the revenue that should go to writers, artists, coders, thinkers, designers, musicians, artists, publishers, presenters, promoters, entertainers, salesman, broadcasters, manufacturers, etc. goes to FANG. And the false, fake, scammy, spammy, and disingenuous are constantly aiming to overthrow the true, the real, the original, and the authentic, all to snag views and clicks, or to trick customers into one thing or another. That feels like a pretty big design flaw.

1 Like

Thanks, Ted.

1 Like